Friday, November 28, 2008

Thinking

We did a little exercise on context, linking and imagery questions and on the whole this was well done. Splendid! If you’re still not sure, check the Language Skills book (see last week’s post).

We then looked at chapters 11 and 12 of “A Patchwork Planet”. In chapter 11, Barnaby visits Opal for her birthday, but the present (chosen by Sophia) falls flat and Opal is cold in the park in her party dress, so she goes home again. He has to wait for Sophia to give him a lift home, which gives him time to think about his marriage. He wonders if perhaps he should have stayed with Natalie and she might have “become the right person”. On the way home in the car, he and Sophia have an argument: she wants him to apply for a job at her bank and is clearly unhappy that he doesn’t earn much; especially since she has “lost” her money in her aunt’s flour bin and for some reason won’t go and retrieve it. (Why do you think she doesn't?)


In chapter 12, he thinks a lot about the problems brought by old age. Then at Mrs Cartwright’s, he and Martine are turning a mattress and end up standing very close to each other. He hears the clink of her overall clasp (on what occasion did he last mention this? – p. 186) and she asks him “How do you get your mouth to turn up at the corners that way?” (How does she feel about mouths? – p. 27). He replies flippantly and changes the subject quickly not wanting to be late for lunch with Sophia. Martine picks a fight with him on the way home and he – apparently – doesn’t know why.

Of course, Anne Tyler knows why. Never forget that this is a novel. Anne Tyler pulls all the strings.

Then we looked at various types of Close Reading questions from a handout which we’ll look further at next week.

4 comments:

emily said...

she does't get the money back because she wants some control over barnaby, she wants to make him feel guilty for taking her for granted.
it's last mentioned when he's undoing the clasp.
she likes mouths, that's the reason that she started going out with her previous boyfriend.

Anonymous said...

Like Emily said, Sophia wants to have some leverage over Barnaby. In the car, she was dropping heavy hints that she'd like him to get a better paying job; her financial situation, while risky for her, might "encourage" Barnaby to consider a career change.

The overall clasp is last mentioned when Barnaby and Martine were rushing to get each other's clothes off.

Martine is attracted to people's mouths; she started dating Everett because he had a nice mouth and is attracted to Barnaby because of his mouth.

-Chris

Mattt_Ellis said...

I HAVE READ IT!!!!

Kelda said...

I think sophia likes to hold that aganst him, she uses this money to try convince him to get a better job and to controle him. I think the last mention of the overall clasp was when baranby cheets on sophia with martine.
baraby notices martines forehead he has a thing for foreheads just as martine likes mouths and is atracked to barnaby becasue of his.
See you in 15 minits.